Dumbed Down Ubuntu
Whilst I am in full support of making computers accessible to everyone, I don’t believe that everyone should have to use them in the same way.
I’ve been an Ubuntu user for, I reckon, three years, and Debian for years before that. In that time, it’s been great to use – install, get on with doing what I do, minimal fuss. But like Windows, the people behind Ubuntu just had to make the user interface ‘easier’ and ‘better’, but they’ve done it at the expense of power-user functionality.
I am a power-user, I know what I’m doing. I don’t think it’s elitist to want to have a UI that lets me get on with my work, one that doesn’t have graphical elements fading on and off the page gently whilst you’re trying to work. One where you can grab the bottom left or right hand corners of a window to resize it, or even one where the close, minimise and maximise windows are in the same place all the time. Ubuntu is no longer that.
I can’t quite put my finger on what’s changed, but it no longer feels efficient. One of the bigger gripes I have is the ‘thingy’ on the left with the large icons. I don’t know the name of it, but it has a set of hideously large icons which come on-screen when I hover near them, and disappear after. I don’t want that – I want to be able to throw a handful of icons in the bar at the top of the screen, and access anything else via a drop-down menu.
I want decent scrollbars back, like in Chrome – not a control that appears outside the window when I hover my mouse in a specific place. My Terminal window is easy to re-size using the top left and top right corners, but next to impossible to resize at the bottom left and right – that’s the way I want to re-size my windows.
Apparently, I can Install the ‘Classic’ desktop in Ubuntu 11.10, but with plenty of caveats. Having done that, my desktop looks even less usable.
Sorry, Ubuntu – I think I’ll revert back to Debian, at least until you’ve sorted yourself out.
If you’re going to Debian, don’t go to Debian unstable or testing as GNOME 3′s arrival is imminent…unless that is you like “hideously large icons” or want to try your luck at Debian’s GNOME Fallback (which except for using the Adwaita theme isn’t that different from Ubuntu’s).
I however don’t consider Ubuntu 11.10 to be dumb or dumbed down. (What do those terms mean anyway?) I, for one, appreciate icons that are bigger than 22 pixels. And I don’t see how making things easier and better is a bad thing.
The thingy on the left is called the launcher. Try Ubuntu’s built in help for some terminology, tips and tricks.
Resizing from the bottom corners works fine here. While the window control buttons was a controversial move when first introduced, it actually makes a fair amount of sense with maximized windows in Unity.
Scrollbars are better in 11.10 than they were in 11.04 and will be better yet in 12.04. If you can’t stand them, here’s a power user tip:
sudo apt-get purge liboverlay-scrollbar-0.2-0 liboverlay-scrollbar3-0.2-0
What Jeremy said, pretty much.
As an alternative, I am running Linux Mint Debian Edition alongside 11.04 on my elderly Thinkpad. I like Unity but it’s an old machine and LMDE runs a bit quicker, especially under LXDE which saves 100MB or so RAM over GNOME 2. LMDE is a bit more civilised and polished than raw Debian – and I’m a weenie, despite ~ΒΌ century of Unix experience.
Honestly, Unity is not bad if you get used to it. Learn the keystrokes – use the keystroke-prompter wallpaper for a while until you get used to it. (They’re smeg-all use to me, personally, as using IBM notebooks and classic IBM keyboards on my desktop, I don’t have Windows keys – but the shortcuts are there and are plentiful.)
I am reaching the point of preferring Unity to GNOME 2 now, and Unity 1.1 in 11.10 is distinctly more polished than the 1.0 version in 11.04. Either of them is a great deal more familiar and coherent and usable than GNOME Shell in GNOME 3.
If you really can’t hack Unity but you still like Ubuntu’s polish, then your best bet is Xubuntu. (Debian never adopted GNOME 2.32 and GNOME 3 components are creeping in – I think a switch to GNOME 3 is inevitable.) Xfce can be configured to be the spitting image of the GNOME 2 desktop.
Piece O’ cake. Install XFCE. Enjoy!
[...] About « Dumbed Down Ubuntu [...]
I couldn’t agree with Peter about Unity. Although I will admit that 11.10 brought a better Unity then 11.04. I gave it a good 2 months and even messed around with compiz config, ubuntu tweak and unity 2d. I just found myself wanting the old gnome back.
I am going to try out Mint, XFCE and Debian though, I have been a Ubuntu die hard for a while. I did like Lubuntu for my older comps.